• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
Coopers Pen - beach party

Bad news for Coopers Pen: Court of Appeal upholds ruling in squatter case

May 17, 2016
Meet Paulette Reid-Denson, Trelawny’s Queen of the Arts

Meet Paulette Reid-Denson, Trelawny’s Queen of the Arts

March 19, 2020
HandJ sidebar banner green yellow

Vacancy for Gym Instructor/Trainer at H&J Fitness 4 Life

February 10, 2020
accident - braco - white car

Two Killed in Car-Truck Collision on Braco Main Road (Video)

December 22, 2019
crime-scene-blue-light-1675687_1280

Man Killed, Woman in Custody After Stabbing Incident in Martha Brae Bar

December 20, 2019
boxing in falmouth jamaica - shakeema mullings

Professional Boxing Comes to Falmouth, Trelawny for the First Time this Friday, December 20

December 18, 2019
ogh medicinal marijuana farm ground breaking

Organic Growth Holdings Medicinal Hemp Farm in Trelawny officially begins planting

December 13, 2019
murder-rate-in-trelawny-st-james

Double murder rocks quiet South Trelawny community

November 26, 2019
marriott al amaterra all-inclusive trelawny 1280

Marriott International to Build All-Inclusive Resort in Trelawny

November 25, 2019
Yahjam web services 8 cornwall street falmouth trelawny jamaica

Yahjam Web Services, Now Open in Falmouth: Trelawny’s First Digital Agency Offers a New Way of Attracting Customers

November 24, 2019
arrested

After 3 years, St Ann man charged with murder, wounding with intent

September 25, 2019
Government Reports A Steady Recovery In Sweet Yam Production In Trelawny

Government Reports A Steady Recovery In Sweet Yam Production In Trelawny

September 25, 2019
March on Gordon House for Cockpit Country

Over 200 March on Gordon House in Support of the Cockpit Country

September 19, 2019
  • Accident
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Travel
Sunday, January 24, 2021
Falmouth News
  • Development
    H10_CORALSPRINGS_-10

    Ocean Coral Spring, Jamaica’s Newest All-Inclusive Resort Opens in Trelawny November, 2019

    police stations to be refurbished - roc

    Clark’s Town Police Station Among 14 Police Stations To Be Renovated Under Project ROC

    Compound 77 cornwall street falmouth trelawny jamaica

    Compound in Falmouth to be Rebuilt Under HOPE Housing Project

    Falmouth drop-in centre for the homeless and indigent almost ready

    Falmouth drop-in centre for the homeless and indigent almost ready

    trelawny traffic light installation

    Historic Installation of Trelawny’s First Traffic Lights Has Begun

    MP Victor Wright Lashes Out At Poor Management of Trelawny’s Development

    Trending Tags

    • Crime
      crime-scene-blue-light-1675687_1280

      Man Killed, Woman in Custody After Stabbing Incident in Martha Brae Bar

      arrested

      After 3 years, St Ann man charged with murder, wounding with intent

      black man in handcuff 2

      Falmouth escapee on murder charge is now back in custody

      Prisoner on murder charge escapes police custody in Falmouth

      Prisoner on murder charge escapes police custody in Falmouth

      Walther PPK .380

      Illegal Gun Seizure in Deeside, Trelawny Results in Arrest of Man and Teenage Girl

      police-murder-862341_1280

      Man of unsound mind who was recently suspected of sex crime, shot dead in Race Course

      Trending Tags

      • Sports
        boxing in falmouth jamaica - shakeema mullings

        Professional Boxing Comes to Falmouth, Trelawny for the First Time this Friday, December 20

        william knibb vs cedric titus

        William Knibb Defeat Cedric Titus 1-0 to Remain Unbeaten Zone C Leaders in DaCosta Cup

        Joe James’ never got dying wish to see family, including famous son David James

        Joe James’ never got dying wish to see family, including famous son David James

        Knibb vs Holland

        William Knibb Defeat Holland High in DaCosta Cup Derby

        Village-Seba-2008-Apr-27_-17

        Weak leadership hurting football in western Jamaica by Adrian Frater

        Jamaica wins 2019 LATAM Cup ice hockey

        Jamaica wins Ice Hockey’s 2019 Amerigol LATAM Cup

        Trending Tags

        • Port
          Oasis of the Seas maiden voyage to Falmouth 2011

          Falmouth worst hit as Jamaica’s cruise passenger numbers plunge this summer

          MP Victor Wright Lashes Out At Poor Management of Trelawny’s Development

          Sheona Muschett - Mark Hylton 1600

          Port Authority commits to Trelawny health sector with donation to Friends of Falmouth Hospital

          cocaine-drugs-908533_1600

          St. Lucian caught attempting to board ship in Falmouth with one pound of cocaine

          Falmouth Port Craft Vending

          Falmouth Artisan Village construction to begin soon for completion end of 2018

          Cruise ship visitors leaving Falmouth Pier

          TPDCo Implements Measures to Prevent Tourist Harassment in Falmouth and Beyond

          Trending Tags

          • Attractions
            Martha Brae Rafts destroyed

            Martha Brae River Rafting fleet almost completely destroyed

            Falmouth Port Craft Vending

            Falmouth Artisan Village construction to begin soon for completion end of 2018

            Jamaica Culinary Tours and Pepper’s Jerk Center Featured on The Daily Meal

            Jamaica Culinary Tours and Pepper’s Jerk Center Featured on The Daily Meal

            Peppers Jerk Center - Clint Rennie

            Pepper’s Jerk Center in Falmouth is Refurbishing and Expanding for the Future

            Allure of the Seas in Falmouth Port

            Jamaican living in Canada to construct Culture Market in Trelawny – construction begins this month

            Paintball Jamaica hit

            Video: Paintballing like a pro at Paintball Jamaica near Falmouth Trelawny

            Trending Tags

            • Classifieds
              • Place Your Ad
            No Result
            View All Result
            Falmouth News
            No Result
            View All Result
            Home Falmouth Jamaica Housing

            Bad news for Coopers Pen: Court of Appeal upholds ruling in squatter case

            May 17, 2016
            in Housing
            7 min read
            0
            Coopers Pen - beach party

            Blue Waters Beach Club in Coopers Pen, Trelawny

            21
            SHARES
            91
            VIEWS
            Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
            Coopers Pen - beach party
            Blue Waters Beach Club in Coopers Pen, Trelawny (photo via Facebook)

            The Court of Appeal has upheld a ruling against the Ministry of Housing that sought to compulsorily acquire the private lands that is known as Coopers Pen.

            The Ministry was seeking to acquire the land in favour of hapless residents, who have been battling an eviction order to evacuate land officially called land Orange Grove, in Trelawny parish, which is owned by New Falmouth Resorts Limited.

            fitness 4life vacancy thumbnail

            RelatedPosts

            Compound 77 cornwall street falmouth trelawny jamaica

            Compound in Falmouth to be Rebuilt Under HOPE Housing Project

            September 9, 2019

            The strongest claim of Cooper’s Pen residents is that former Prime Minister Michael Manley told them some time in the 1970’s that they could have the land. That promise came with no ‘paper’ or documentary proof. Indeed, it had no ‘teeth’ as the land was already privately owned.

            With the impending development of Falmouth, and by extension, Trelawny, many silent owners of real estate started coming forward. New Falmouth began proceedings against the Coppers Pen residents in 2007. In April 2010, Falmouth Resort Limited (owned by John Chisholm) won the case. Not only did he win the case that they should leave the land, but he was also awarded damages of $50,000 to be paid by each of the 99 defendants in the case.

            In February 2012, The National Housing Trust (NHT) stepped in. They designated the property an “improvement area” under Section 6 of the Housing Act, and one month later, applied for a stay of execution of the 2010 judgment.

            Now with the upholding of he ruling by the Court of Appeal, the game seems to be over for Coopers Pen. It now seems that the only recourse is for the residents to be evicted. It will be interesting to see if and how they may be given another lifeline.

            Just as the Bamboo Village is no more, this ruling threatens to wipe out the entire Cooper’s Pen community, comprising of more than 100 residences.

            Coopers Pen is best known for their football team, and craft vendors, who plied their trade in the now non-existent Bamboo Village, the spot on which a new multi-storied hotel (now the tallest building in Trelawny) is being constructed.

            Coopers Pen FC
            Coopers Pen Football Club

            Coopers Pen is also home to Royalton Hotel, Mangos Jamaica Hotel, Blue Waters Beach Club and Burwood Beach. The land in question though, is not beach land, but across the road from the beach. Relatively close by is also the Outameni property (ironically, the NHT was also at the losing end of this deal). The area is therefore prime real estate property in the growing parish.

             

            Full Story:

            The Court of Appeal has upheld a ruling that barred the minister of housing from compulsorily acquiring privately owned land in Trelawny, saying the takeover did not serve a public purpose as required by law, but was done for the benefit of squatters.

            The land at Orange Grove, Trelawny, is owned by New Falmouth Resorts Limited, which in 2007 brought a claim against 99 defendants occupying the land, for recovery of possession.

            New Falmouth, which is controlled and chaired by James Chisholm, won the case in a decision handed down in April 2010 by Justice Donald McIntosh, who ordered that the land revert to the private owner and awarded damages of $50,000 to be paid by each defendant.

            Nearly two years later, in February 2012, the minister of housing designated the property an “improvement area” under Section 6 of the Housing Act, to facilitate its compulsory acquisition; and applied for a stay of execution of McIntosh’s 2010 judgment the following month.

            McIntosh denied the application, saying it was an attempt to pervert the course of justice and an abuse of the processes of the court.

            “It may be that the law is not a shackle to the lawmakers,” the Supreme Court judge said. But: “That does not apply to the court, which must dispense justice according to the law,” he added.

            The reproach appears to hark back to the now infamous, albeit partial quotation from five political administrations ago when then Prime Minister P.J. Patterson, himself a renowned lawyer and Queen’s Counsel, declared that “the law is not a shackle …”.

            Despite his reproach, the judge was empathetic towards the defendants. “Given the history of this case, the length of the trial and the efforts made by the court to assist the defendants, who seem to have been misled by politicians into squatting on private property, notwithstanding their unlawful act, this court empathises with the gullible defendants,” Justice McIntosh wrote.

            He gave permission for the 99 defendants to appeal his decision, but they did not follow through.

            The minister of housing, however, sought to relitigate the case in March 2012, through an application before the Supreme Court, for a stay of McIntosh’s judgment and injunctive relief. That case was heard by Justice Lennox Campbell, who subsequently threw out the application in 2013.

            The housing minister appealed Campbell’s decision the following year. But the Court of Appeal’s decision, written by Justice Frank Williams and handed down two weeks ago on April 29, continued to favour New Falmouth.

            It also detailed actions taken by the Government to hold on to the property.

            On May 1, 2012, three days before Justice McIntosh’s initial decision to refuse the stay of execution, the minister lodged a caveat against the certificate of title for lands registered to New Falmouth Resorts, including the Orange Grove property, and gazetted the notice declaring the lands as an “improvement area”.

            Two weeks later, on May 18, the minister sought a declaration from the court that he was entitled to compulsorily acquire the Orange Grove lands and sought an injunction against New Falmouth. That application was supported by the affidavit of Simone Morris-Rattray, senior manager in the legal services department and company secretary of the Housing Agency of Jamaica (HAJ).

            Abuse of process

            New Falmouth responded with an application on October 22 to strike out the housing minister ’s claim. Justice Campbell ruled in favour of New Falmouth on May 21, 2013, saying the minister’s application was an abuse of process.

            It was from Justice Campbell’s decision that the appeal, filed on March 27, 2014, emanated.

            Attorneys Susan Reid-Jones and Vanessa Blair, who represented the housing minister, argued before the Court of Appeal that Justice Campbell erred in accepting the submissions of lawyers for New Falmouth Resorts that the issues in the claim had already been adjudicated. They also contended that the minister was not a party to the claim before Justice McIntosh, saying that matter was private-law action brought by New Falmouth for recovery of possession.

            However, Williams agreed with Justice Campbell’s finding that all the applications were, in substance, based on the minister’s compulsory acquisition of the land. Their common aim, he said, was to prevent the orders of Justice McIntosh from taking effect.

            On Thursday, attorney Keith Bishop, one of the lawyers who represented New Falmouth Resorts, said the section of the property in question is still being squatted on. He said Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal have given consistent orders for the illegal occupants to vacate the property; and that – barring further appeal – the next step is to enforce those orders and for the defendants to pay over damages granted by the Supreme Court to New Falmouth.

            Bishop and his colleagues, Juliet MairRose and Romaine Tulloch, argued in the appeal trial – and the Court of Appeal agreed – that the minister sought to obtain compulsory acquisition in a ‘backhanded’ manner, reopening a closed case by using the ‘crutch of compulsory acquisition’.

            The Court of Appeal took note of the statutory declaration of Janice Buchanan-McLean, legal officer of the HAJ, that the Government feared public upheaval in Trelawny were the squatters to be displaced in compliance with the court order, but was more inclined to side with Justice Campbell’s thinking on the issue when he wrote that: “The Housing Act and The Land Acquisition Act do not provide for the compulsory acquisition of privately owned land in order to transfer an interest to a community of persons who have occupied those lands despite the efforts of the owner to evict, and in defiance of orders of the Supreme Court.”

            Justice Williams also sided with the view expressed by Justice McIntosh that “the Constitution protects private property, and does not provide cover for the acquisition of private property in order to regularise the unlawful occupation of squatters”.

            mcpherse.thompson@gleanerjm.com

             

            Source: The Gleaner.

            Tags: coopers penJohn ChisolmJustice McIntoshNew Falmouth Resortnhtsquatting
            Share21TweetSend
            Previous Post

            New Falmouth Market on target for 3rd quarter opening

            Next Post

            Falmouth Trelawny supermarket owner fined for stocking illegal rum

            Related Posts

            Compound 77 cornwall street falmouth trelawny jamaica
            Development

            Compound in Falmouth to be Rebuilt Under HOPE Housing Project

            by Editor
            September 9, 2019
            Next Post
            J Wray & Nephew Rum

            Falmouth Trelawny supermarket owner fined for stocking illegal rum

            Leave a Reply Cancel reply

            Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

            I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

            HandJ sidebar banner green yellow 336x475

            Most Popular News Today

            • H10_CORALSPRINGS_-10

              Ocean Coral Spring, Jamaica’s Newest All-Inclusive Resort Opens in Trelawny November, 2019

              846 shares
              Share 846 Tweet 0
            • Person of interest held in the killing of a Trelawny woman in Runaway Bay

              73 shares
              Share 73 Tweet 0
            • List of Jamaica’s Top 24 Ranked Schools in Academics – Trelawny’s Westwood High Ranked #6

              2 shares
              Share 0 Tweet 0
            • Auto parts remanufacturing plant coming to Hague, Trelawny

              191 shares
              Share 191 Tweet 0
            • Trelawny Co-Operative Credit Union celebrates its 50th anniversary

              104 shares
              Share 104 Tweet 0
            • Double murder in Hyde, Clark’s Town on Friday night

              45 shares
              Share 45 Tweet 0
            • Principal of Falmouth Prep School awarded by Seventh Day Adventist Church

              199 shares
              Share 199 Tweet 0

            Advertisement

            Most Popular This Month

            • Trending
            • Comments
            • Latest
            westwood high trelawny

            List of Jamaica’s Top 24 Ranked Schools in Academics – Trelawny’s Westwood High Ranked #6

            July 21, 2015
            H10_CORALSPRINGS_-10

            Ocean Coral Spring, Jamaica’s Newest All-Inclusive Resort Opens in Trelawny November, 2019

            September 20, 2019
            sakura express

            New Restaurant Opens In Falmouth Called Sakura Express – The Simple Changes That Are Punishing Other Local Restaurants

            July 5, 2015
            guinep-health-benefits

            The Health Benefits of Guinep

            October 12, 2018
            Fatal Accident Salt Marsh Main Road

            Two killed in crash on Salt Marsh Main Road

            February 1, 2018
            Meet Paulette Reid-Denson, Trelawny’s Queen of the Arts

            Meet Paulette Reid-Denson, Trelawny’s Queen of the Arts

            March 19, 2020
            HandJ sidebar banner green yellow

            Vacancy for Gym Instructor/Trainer at H&J Fitness 4 Life

            February 10, 2020
            accident - braco - white car

            Two Killed in Car-Truck Collision on Braco Main Road (Video)

            December 22, 2019
            crime-scene-blue-light-1675687_1280

            Man Killed, Woman in Custody After Stabbing Incident in Martha Brae Bar

            December 20, 2019
            boxing in falmouth jamaica - shakeema mullings

            Professional Boxing Comes to Falmouth, Trelawny for the First Time this Friday, December 20

            December 18, 2019

            Follow Us On Facebook

            • About
            • Contact
            • Privacy Policy
            • Privacy Tools

            Copyright © 2019 Falmouth News.

            No Result
            View All Result
            • Development
            • Crime
            • Sports
            • Port
            • Attractions
            • Classifieds
              • Place Your Ad

            Copyright © 2019 Falmouth News.

            Login to your account below

            Forgotten Password?

            Fill the forms bellow to register

            *By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
            All fields are required. Log In

            Retrieve your password

            Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

            Log In
            This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.